• About Us
  • Brain Injury Network (BIN)
  • Abuse, Expoitation, Victimization
  • Academic Attribution
  • Blast Exposure Brain Injury
  • Ban Football
  • Brain Injury Survivor Priorities
  • Brain Injury Advocacy by and for People
  • Brain Injury Advocates Book
  • Brain Injury Network Forums
  • Brain Injury Survivor Identifiers
  • Brain Injury Survivor Movement
  • By and For the Brain Injury Survivors
  • California Dept. of Rehabilitation
  • California or Local
  • Calif. Senate Health Committee Testimony
  • Cautionary Tale
  • College Disability Programs
  • Contact Us
  • DOR CA TBI
  • Easy Picture Links
  • Easy Text Version
  • Health Care Reform
  • Hospital Trauma Centers
  • How You Can Help
  • Human Rights of People With Brain Injury
  • International Standards
  • Laws and Legislation
  • Lawyers and Attorneys
  • LInk To Us
  • LINKS
  • Mandated Reporters
  • mTBI and Neuroimaging
  • National Standards
  • Online Community
  • Please Donate to the BIN
  • Policy Advocacy ABI Forum
  • Post-Acute Sequelae of Covid-19 (PASC)
  • Postsecondary BI Programs
  • Postsecondary Protocols
  • Post-TBI Syndrome Dear Medical Community
  • Privacy Policy
  • Protect Your Privacy
  • Public Policy
  • Public Policy in Chronological Order
  • Public Policy Index
    • Best Practice Guidelines
    • Bicycle Helmet Law
    • Brain Injury Community
    • Brain Injury and Parental Rights
    • Building Code Standards
    • Classification of TBI
    • Clinical Research
    • Cognitive Retraining
    • Community Reintegration
    • Comprehensive Health Reform
    • Concussion and Sports
    • Conflict of Interest in Medical Research
    • Counselor Training
    • Crime
    • Department of Mental Health
    • Devicing While Driving
    • Disability Rights and Issues
    • Disclosures, Advocates
    • Disclosures, Medical Providers
    • Disclosures, Researchers
    • Disclosures, Web Sites
    • Doctor Education
    • Driving While Devicing
    • Drug Companies
    • Empowerment, Patient
    • Exposing Brain Injury Survivors' Identie
    • Feeding Tube
    • Financial Institutions
    • Fluorescent Lighting Mandate Waiver
    • Food and Water
    • Funding Priorities for Survivors
    • Gold Standard Research Studies
    • Helmet Laws
    • High School Graduation
    • Hospital Privacy and Consent
    • Hospital Settings and Patients
    • Hospital Trauma Centers in the USA
    • Human Research Guidelines
    • Identification as People
    • Law-Abiding Survivors
    • Incarcerated Criminals with ABI
    • Law Enforcement
    • Laws and Recommendation
    • Least Restrictive Living Environment
    • Living Environments
    • Local and County Services
    • Locked Facilities
    • Mandated Medical Review
    • Mandated Reporter Law
    • Medical Device Makers
    • Mental Illness
    • National Centers: Costly Duplication
    • Nursing Home Placements
    • Nutrition and Hydration
    • Online Recruitment of Patients
    • Patient Recruitment to Medical Studies
    • Organizations or Providers Offering Mone
    • Parental Rights and Brain Injury
    • Patient Data Harvesting
    • Patient Empowerment
    • Persistent Vegetative State (PVS)
    • Persistent Wakeful but Unaware State
    • Physician Disclosures
    • Political Correctness
    • Political Sensitivity
    • Post-Acute Medical Environments
    • PostConcussion Syndrome
    • PCS is Physiological in Origin
    • Post-Secondary Education
    • Post-Secondary Programs
    • Privacy Online
    • Privacy Settings on Web Sites
    • Profiting from Exposing Our Identities
    • Psychologist and Counselor Training
    • Psychotropic Drugs, Use of
    • PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder)
    • Post-TBI Syndrome-Proposal
    • QEEG
    • Raising Money to Promote Med. Research
    • Recruitment Methodology
    • Removal of Life Support
    • Research Studies Full Disclosure
    • School Age Children with ABI
    • Sports or Athletics Activities
    • Skiing and Helmets
    • Social Community On-Line Networking
    • Social Media Recruitment
    • Sports Medical Review
    • Stakeholders, Third Party
    • State Brain Injury Survivor Councils
    • Stigma and Brain Injury
    • Stigma, Marginalization, Stereotypical
    • Strokes are not TBIs
    • Subclassification Hierarchy of ABI
    • Support Group Facilitation
    • Survivor Advocacy
    • Survivor Advocates
    • Survivor Identity, Exposure of
    • Survivor Community Priorities
    • Survivor Stories in Media
    • TBI is a Subset of ABI
    • Terminology
    • The Term "Survivor"
    • Universal Health Care
    • Veterans, US Armed Forces
    • Victimization
  • Search This Site or the Net
  • Services Prioritization
  • Survivor Advisory Council
  • Survivors As Stakeholders
  • The Survivors' Point of View
    • A Chronic Disease
    • A Cure for Brain Injury?
    • A Stroke is Not a TBI
    • Advocates: Conflicts of Interest
    • Brain Injury Awareness
    • Brain Injury Support Groups
    • Can We Be "Trained"?
    • Definitions of ABI and TBI
    • Facebook Is Not Safe
    • 2009 Independence Day Message
    • Internet Providers Share Your Info
    • Medical Designations
    • Our Own Advocacy
    • Politically Correct Terminology
    • Post-TBi Syndrome (PTBIS)
    • Research, Clinical Trials, Studies and P
    • SABI Brain Injury Advocacy Forum
    • SABI
    • Survivor Organizations
    • Social Communities
    • Use of the Term "Survivor"
    • Why We Need Collective Advocacy
  • What We Survivors Need
  • Who Represents Us?
  • Worldwide Brain Injury Community Awarene
  • Blank 2
Donate
DONATE

Advocates: Conflicts of Interest

Third-Party Advocates

Third-party advocates hold themselves out as supporters, proponents, defenders, and champions. They must be completely on the side of the persons that they represent. As "advocates" for individuals with brain injury, they must put first what is in the best interest of their patients or clients. They can have no conflict of interest that might interfere or compete with their first duty, which is to the people they represent, guide, coach, sustain or counsel.

"Advocates" and Advocate Disclosures: Programs, Studies and Trials

I would like to mention to everyone that recently the Brain Injury Network published a new public policy on ". Please see this policy and other policies in our public policy section. We are concerned that many so-called or actual "advocates" for people with brain injuries have conflicts of interest. While they might proclaim they are advocates, they may also have some kind of business interest in being advocates for us. Sometimes these advocates are employed by businesses. Sometimes the interests of these business entities are not quite the same as the interests of we survivors ourselves, although, of course, there is overlap. However, if there is any possibility of a conflict of interest it should be disclosed by the "advocate" to we survivors or, if necessary in the case of survivors who are not competent, survivors' families. This is what we would like to see, but, of course currently this is not the case. However, I can advise you to be on the look-out when you are weighing your options. I can advise you to carefully assess the credentials of any "advocate" counseling you.
What would be examples of a potential conflict of interest?
1. The "advocate" works for a non-profit, an association for example, and has the job to counsel us or help us. But the "advocate" also has a paid job at a rehabilitation facility and is looking for paying patients. This is a conflict of interest that should be disclosed to the survivor being counseled by the advocate.
2. The "advocate" works for a medical company specializing in securing people to participate in clinical trials. The company even has a "patient advocacy" department that this "advocate" works for. The main purpose of this company is to secure people to participate in clinical trial(s). The company benefits financially by securing people to participate in clinical trials. This should be disclosed up front.
3. The "advocate" works for a company or hospital, etc. that is itself doing a clinical trial. This trial needs study participants. The main purpose of this advocate is to secure people to go into the clinical trial. This should be disclosed up front.
In these cases the "advocate" who is "advocating" for us and/or "counseling" us wants us to go to particular rehab programs or to participate in trials. This is a conflict of interest. It may be perfectly fine to go to that particular program or into a clinical trial, but the "advocate" needs to disclose this true purpose of his or her "advocacy" and his or her employment with a business concern up front.
The advocates in the above scenarios will steer you to "their program" or "trial" or "study". Since they have an interest other than just you to represent, you must view them with caution. This is not to say that what they offer might not be good for you, but you must make that determination independently with truly unbiased professional counsel. There are many medical considerations to be weighed as to whether or not you should participate, and these matters should be gone over by you and your trusted medical advisors. So please go over any offers for these sorts of programs and trials and studies with medical people you actually know and trust.

  • See also: Research, Clinical Trials
  • See also: Public Policy Advocates: Disclosures

ABI/TBI Definitions, About BIN, Ban Dangerous Sports,Brain Injury Advocacy, Brain Injury Forums,Brain Injury Names, By and or Brain Injury Survivors, California Area BIN, Cautionary Tale, Classification, Contact Us, Chronic Disease?, Concussions and Football, Distribution List, Easy Version, Global Issues,Health Care Reform, Home, How You Can Help, Human, Legal and Civil Rights, Independence, International Standards, Laws and Legislation, Links, Mandated Reporters, National Standards, News, Online Community, Please Donate, Postsecondary Program Protocols, Post-TBI Syndrome, Privacy Policy, Protect Your Privacy Public Policy, Public Policy Index, Research/Clinical Trials/Studies, SABI Advocacy Forum, SEARCH, Shop OnLine and Help BIN, The Survivor Movement, The Survivors' Viewpoint,Terminology, Who Really Represents Us, Who We Are,Worldwide Brain Injury Community,Your Privacy Settings on the Internet
© Copyright 1998-2023. Brain Injury Network
All rights reserved.

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website, and analyze website traffic. By clicking Accept you consent to our use of cookies. Read about how we use cookies.

Your Cookie Settings

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website, and analyze website traffic. Read about how we use cookies.

Cookie Categories
Essential

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our websites. You cannot refuse these cookies without impacting how our websites function. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings, as described under the heading "Managing cookies" in the Privacy and Cookies Policy.

Analytics

These cookies collect information that is used in aggregate form to help us understand how our websites are being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are.